Dr. Michelle Stowers, Principal

Dr. Michelle Stowers began her career as an educator in Bay Shore 27 years ago. This is Dr. Stowers’ tenth year as an administrator in Bay Shore. Prior to becoming principal, she has had many leadership experiences including assistant principal of Mary G. Clarkson School, assistant principal of Brook Avenue School, assistant principal of South Country School, and director of the Eastern Suffolk BOCES Summer Enrichment Program at Bay Shore for ten years.

Dr. Stowers believes strongly in collaborative leadership that supports a school environment of lifelong learning. Dr. Stowers’ educational background includes a Bachelor of Science in Criminal Justice from Pace University with minors in Spanish and history, a Master’s of Science in Teaching from Pace University, a Master’s of Science in Educational Technology from Queens College, a Master’s of Arts in Educational Administration and Supervision from Adelphi University, and a Doctorate from Hofstra University in Educational Leadership and Policy Studies.

Dr. Stowers is a visionary leader who is dedicated to providing Bay Shore students with a rewarding educational experience and a quality education. She is excited to bring passion, enthusiasm and level of experience that will help to cultivate the unique educational programs that Fifth Avenue School has to offer.

Ms. Kayleigh Navarra, Assistant Principal

Kayleigh Navarra began her teaching career in Jacksonville, North Carolina as a third-grade teacher before returning home to Long Island, N.Y., to join the Bay Shore School District. She taught grades 3–5 at Gardiner Manor School before transitioning to Mary G. Clarkson School in 2022, where she served as the STEAM Instructional Specialist.

Ms. Navarra holds a Bachelor’s of Science in Childhood Education from SUNY College at Old Westbury and a Master’s of Education in Learning and Emerging Technologies from Empire State University. She also earned a Certificate of Advanced Study in School Building Leadership and School District Leadership at Molloy University.

Ms. Navarra brings a deep passion for innovation and a heartfelt commitment to creating a supportive, inclusive environment where students, staff, and families can thrive. She believes in the power of encouragement, creativity, and connection to inspire learning and growth. She looks forward to building meaningful relationships and helping each child reach their fullest potential.